12.06.09
The Speed of Flash Drives
When buying my new graphics card I received a free 4GB flash drive. I didn’t realize this when I bought the product, but I was excited as you can never have too many flash drives! However, as I read its reviews I heard a great many complaints of it being slow. This made me wonder just how fast it would be, and how it compared to my other flash drives.
I was fortunate enough to be one of the first people to jump on the flash drive bandwagon. I bought (well, my mother bought) my first flash drive, a massive 128MB for over $120. That is a joke now days of course — you can obtain giant flash drives cheaply, and people routinely hand out “small” 4GB drives for free. And, as long as you plug them in once every twenty or so years they’ll retain their data!
Here I will detail the analysis of the flash drives I currently own, from my oldest, original 128 MB PNY flash to the newest free OCZ drive I have received.
In the order they were acquired, here is make / capacity (note that my original drive is the largest physically, even compared to the 16GB drive):

- 128MB PNY Attache (bought around mid 2004 or early 2005. It came with a Windows 98/ME drivers disc that I carry in my backpack to this day)
- 128 MB UNI ROTC – Special drive received from the department when I was in high school
- 2GB SanDisk Cruzer Micro – My first flash drive in many years. 2GB seems like a lot when you are used to 128MB!
- 16GB Kingston Data Traveler – Received from Distek, my employer, as Christmas gift in 2008.
- 4GB OCZ Diesel – Received as a free addon by NewEgg for buying two video cards.
—
I will test using CrystalDiskMark 2.2 using a USB 2.0 port doing sequential reads and writes:
| Drive | Filesystem | Read (MB/s) | Write (MB/s) |
| PNY 128MB | FAT | 4.858 | 4.172 |
| ROTC 128MB | FAT | 10.71 | 4.891 |
| SanDisk Cruzer 2GB | FAT32 | 30.51 | 8.950 |
| Kingston Data Traveler 16GB | FAT32 | 22.17 | 14.11 |
| OCZ Diesel 4GB | FAT32 | 17.84 | 6.498 |
–
The conclusions are quite interesting. In comparison to similar technology, the OCZ diesel is indeed slow. There are many drives that function much faster then the ones listed here, though these are some of the more common drives.
It is interesting to me that write speeds increased dramatically, but now seem to wax and wane depending on what you buy. I also find it interesting that there was no clear winner here. The Kingston drive would be the obvious choice with good read speeds and the best write speeds, as well as superior capacity. However, the Sandisk drive has superior read speeds by a fair amount, and at 2GB will hold most anything I would want to carry around. I suppose these will be my primary drives depending on what I am trying to do.
As for the free OCZ Diesel… well, I think it is time to test ReadyBoost with all 4GB of it